Ail Gynllun Datblygu Lleol Adneuo Diwygiedig Sir Gaerfyrddin
Chwilio sylwadau
Canlyniadau chwilio The Home Builders Federation
Chwilio o’r newyddGwrthwynebu
Ail Gynllun Datblygu Lleol Adneuo Diwygiedig Sir Gaerfyrddin
5.6
ID sylw: 4764
Derbyniwyd: 11/04/2023
Ymatebydd: The Home Builders Federation
Cydymffurfio â’r gyfraith? Ydi
Cadarn? Ydi
Under the 'A Prosperous Carmarthenshire' section the need for new homes to support economic growth should be included.
No.19 should be amended to remove reference to the five year land supply which is no longer relevant in Wales.
No.21 What housing sites are these previous allocations?
Under the 'A Prosperous Carmarthenshire' section the need for new homes to support economic growth should be included.
No.19 The wording should comment on compliance with the trajectory.
No.21 The type of site not being delivered should be explained.
Under the 'A Prosperous Carmarthenshire' section the need for new homes to support economic growth should be included.
No.19 should be amended to remove reference to the five year land supply which is no longer relevant in Wales.
No.21 What housing sites are these previous allocations?
Comments noted. The matter can be given further consideration during Examination
Gwrthwynebu
Ail Gynllun Datblygu Lleol Adneuo Diwygiedig Sir Gaerfyrddin
AS10 Darparu cymysgedd a nifer priodol o dai o ansawdd ledled y Sir, yn seiliedig ar egwyddorion datblygu economaidd-gymdeithasol cynaliadwy a chyfleoedd cyfartal.
ID sylw: 4765
Derbyniwyd: 11/04/2023
Ymatebydd: The Home Builders Federation
Cydymffurfio â’r gyfraith? Ydi
Cadarn? Ydi
The role of housing in both supporting Economic growth (SO11), Wellbeing (SO2) and Equal opportunities (SO4) should be acknowledged.
Amend the text to acknowledge the role of housing in both supporting Economic growth (SO11), Wellbeing (SO2) and Equal opportunities (SO4).
The role of housing in both supporting Economic growth (SO11), Wellbeing (SO2) and Equal opportunities (SO4) should be acknowledged.
Disagree. The aim of this strategic objective is specific to what is stated i.e making provision for an appropriate number and mix of quality homes across the County. The other SOs highlighted by the respondent are specific to their own objectives and the need to cross reference each SO is not necessary and not in the remit of this section of the Plan.
Gwrthwynebu
Ail Gynllun Datblygu Lleol Adneuo Diwygiedig Sir Gaerfyrddin
Atodiad 7 – Taflwybr Tai
ID sylw: 4766
Derbyniwyd: 11/04/2023
Ymatebydd: The Home Builders Federation
Cydymffurfio â’r gyfraith? Nac Ydi
Cadarn? Nac Ydi
The figures in the table do not appear to add up, although it is noted that the table is very complicated and hard to follow. Adding the overall allocations, commitments, windfalls, small sites and taking away completions does not result in the identified requirement figure.
Why does the trajectory include a five year land supply calculation as this is not longer required or used in Wales.
Check the figures, remove the five year land supply information and simplify the table and include it in the main document with the housing requirement policy.
The figures in the table do not appear to add up, although it is noted that the table is very complicated and hard to follow. Adding the overall allocations, commitments, windfalls, small sites and taking away completions does not result in the identified requirement figure.
Why does the trajectory include a five year land supply calculation as this is not longer required or used in Wales.
The Council has undertaken additional work to comply with key sections of the DPM and this is addressed within the Position Statement on Housing Growth. This relates to work on the housing trajectory and spatial distribution papers and will be submitted to the Inspector as part of the Council's evidence base.
Gwrthwynebu
Ail Gynllun Datblygu Lleol Adneuo Diwygiedig Sir Gaerfyrddin
11.18
ID sylw: 4767
Derbyniwyd: 11/04/2023
Ymatebydd: The Home Builders Federation
Cydymffurfio â’r gyfraith? Ydi
Cadarn? Ydi
This text is not required as any development would have to comply with these polices and any other relevant policies in the plan.
Delete the paragraph.
This text is not required as any development would have to comply with these polices and any other relevant policies in the plan.
Disagree. The paragraph is included for emphasis / clarification as to what policies will need to be accorded with.
Gwrthwynebu
Ail Gynllun Datblygu Lleol Adneuo Diwygiedig Sir Gaerfyrddin
SG2: Safleoedd wrth Gefn
ID sylw: 4769
Derbyniwyd: 11/04/2023
Ymatebydd: The Home Builders Federation
Cydymffurfio â’r gyfraith? Ydi
Cadarn? Ydi
How do the housing numbers relate to the plans housing figure and the plans flexibility allowance.
It is not currently clear whether or not the housing numbers identified within this policy form part of the current planned housing allocation figure or how they relate to the 10% flexibility allowance.
Question reserved sites being released by a plan review as this could be four years away and would be a process which would allow new housing sites to be allocated if required.
The policy indicates that in bringing sites forward they must not result in 'over provision' clarification is required on how this can be proved, for instance would confirmation that either an allocated site or committed site not come forward due to a change in circumstances be enough or would a committed site planning consent need to lapse.
Provide clarity in either the policy or the supporting text with regard to the comments above.
It is not currently clear whether or not the housing numbers identified within this policy form part of the current planned housing allocation figure or how they relate to the 10% flexibility allowance.
Question reserved sites being released by a plan review as this could be four years away and would be a process which would allow new housing sites to be allocated if required.
The policy indicates that in bringing sites forward they must not result in 'over provision' clarification is required on how this can be proved, for instance would confirmation that either an allocated site or committed site not come forward due to a change in circumstances be enough or would a committed site planning consent need to lapse.
The Reserve sites identified within the Revised LDP do not form part of the housing supply figure. The inclusion of Reserve Sites will be a consideration for the Revised LDP examination
Gwrthwynebu
Ail Gynllun Datblygu Lleol Adneuo Diwygiedig Sir Gaerfyrddin
Polisi Strategol – SP 17: Trafnidiaeth a Hygyrchedd
ID sylw: 4770
Derbyniwyd: 11/04/2023
Ymatebydd: The Home Builders Federation
Cydymffurfio â’r gyfraith? Ydi
Cadarn? Ydi
The policy as worded has no requirements it is just a statement of facts.
Either delete or reword policy.
The policy as worded has no requirements it is just a statement of facts.
Comments noted, consideration to be given to the policy wording at examination.
Gwrthwynebu
Ail Gynllun Datblygu Lleol Adneuo Diwygiedig Sir Gaerfyrddin
CCH4: Ansawdd Dŵr a Diogelu Adnoddau Dŵr
ID sylw: 4771
Derbyniwyd: 11/04/2023
Ymatebydd: The Home Builders Federation
Cydymffurfio â’r gyfraith? Ydi
Cadarn? Ydi
The reference to SuDS in the policy wording is not necessary as it is required by separate legislation. It can if required be referred to in the supporting text.
The final paragraph relating to Phosphates needs to be reworded as mitigation will not be required in all cases due to the approach taken by NRW following the ongoing permit reviews.
Remove reference to SuDS.
Reword paragraph relating to Phosphates.
The reference to SuDS in the policy wording is not necessary as it is required by separate legislation. It can if required be referred to in the supporting text.
The final paragraph relating to Phosphates needs to be reworded as mitigation will not be required in all cases due to the approach taken by NRW following the ongoing permit reviews.
Disagree. PPW makes reference to SuDS and it it’s importance in being integral to the design of new development.
In respect of the second part of the objection, it is considered that the wording of the Policy is appropriate and more guidance will provided in Supplementary Planning Guidance.
Gwrthwynebu
Ail Gynllun Datblygu Lleol Adneuo Diwygiedig Sir Gaerfyrddin
Polisi CCH3 – Pwyntiau Gwefru Cerbydau Trydan
ID sylw: 4774
Derbyniwyd: 11/04/2023
Ymatebydd: The Home Builders Federation
Cydymffurfio â’r gyfraith? Ydi
Cadarn? Nac Ydi
The proposed policy goes beyond the requirements with national policy.
If removal of the policy is not accepted then the requirement should be reduced to require developers to provide a connection point ready for the charging unit but not the actual charging unit. The choice of charging unit should be left to the customer and only needs to be fitted if the customer chooses to own an electric car. The technology associated with EV charging is changing rapidly so will become outdated very quickly.
Remove the policy or reword so that it encourages developers rather than forces.
The proposed policy goes beyond the requirements with national policy.
If removal of the policy is not accepted then the requirement should be reduced to require developers to provide a connection point ready for the charging unit but not the actual charging unit. The choice of charging unit should be left to the customer and only needs to be fitted if the customer chooses to own an electric car. The technology associated with EV charging is changing rapidly so will become outdated very quickly.
Anghytuno. Mae'r Cynllun yn cynnwys amrywiaeth o bolisïau a darpariaethau mewn perthynas â chyfrannu a mynd i'r afael â heriau newid hinsawdd o safbwynt cynllunio defnydd tir, gyda'r polisi hwn yn un. Yn hyn o beth, fe'i paratowyd mewn perthynas â darpariaethau Polisi Cynllunio Cymru a chynlluniau a strategaethau eraill gan gynnwys yr argyfyngau newid yn yr hinsawdd fel y'u datganwyd gan LlC a'r Cyngor.
___
Disagree. The Plan includes a range of policies and provisions in relation to contributing and addressing the challenges of climate change from a land use planning perspective, this policy being one. In this respect it has been prepared with regard to the provisions of PPW and other plans and strategies including the climate change emergencies as declared by the WG and the Council.
Gwrthwynebu
Ail Gynllun Datblygu Lleol Adneuo Diwygiedig Sir Gaerfyrddin
Polisi Strategol – SP 16: Newid yn yr Hinsawdd
ID sylw: 4775
Derbyniwyd: 11/04/2023
Ymatebydd: The Home Builders Federation
Cydymffurfio â’r gyfraith? Ydi
Cadarn? Ydi
The HBF notes that many of the requirements within this policy are repeated in other policies so are unnecessary. They are also covered by national policy in many cases so are unnecessary, an example being SuDS.
Rewording of the policy to avoid duplication should be considered and a more local emphasis should be placed on the requirements of the policy.
The HBF notes that many of the requirements within this policy are repeated in other policies so are unnecessary. They are also covered by national policy in many cases so are unnecessary, an example being SuDS.
Disagree, The wording in this paragraph is considered to be sufficiently robust and in accordance with PPW.
Gwrthwynebu
Ail Gynllun Datblygu Lleol Adneuo Diwygiedig Sir Gaerfyrddin
11.333
ID sylw: 4776
Derbyniwyd: 11/04/2023
Ymatebydd: The Home Builders Federation
Cydymffurfio â’r gyfraith? Ydi
Cadarn? Ydi
The HBF asks for clarifications on why the Policy does not allow for adopting any new public open space as traditionally has been the case. The need for a private management company imposes an additional cost on the home owner and arguably is seen as a double payment of the Council Tax.
Provide clarification on adoption of open space by the Council.
The HBF asks for clarifications on why the Policy does not allow for adopting any new public open space as traditionally has been the case. The need for a private management company imposes an additional cost on the home owner and arguably is seen as a double payment of the Council Tax.
A policy on the adoption of open space by the local authority is outside the remit of the Plan.
