SR/139/002

Object

Representation ID: 355

Received: 02/02/2019

Respondent: Mr Brian Evans

Rwy'n gwrthwynebu cynnwys y safle SR/139/002
1. Gwrthodwyd y safle yn 2014. Ar wahan i'r posibiliad o newid y mynedfa does dim dim arall wedi newid gyda'r un problemau yn parhau.
2. Nid oes gofyn am fwy o dai yn y pentref, gyda tua 20 ar werth ar hyn o bryd.
3. Mae un rhan o'r safle yn dir amaeth da a'r rhan arall yn rhan bwysig o ddraeniad dwr glaw yr ardal. Mae concritio caeau yn mynd i achosi problemau.
4. Nid yw yn estyniad naturiol i'r pentref.
5. Mae nifer y tai awgrymir yn ddatblygiad TREFOL.

Object

Representation ID: 383

Received: 02/02/2019

Respondent: Mr Richard Williams

Proposed scale and density of development is not within character of the current area. Residents of this area have chosen to live in rural surroundings. This development does not fit the character of the area.

Roadway and access is inadequate for a development of this scale.

Loss quality agricultural land (top field)

Frequent issues with flooding and surface water (lower field). Site is not suitable for development.

Considering the nearby development areas (Foelgastell and Cefneithin) it's doubtful that there is demand for another development of this scale in the area.

Object

Representation ID: 396

Received: 03/02/2019

Respondent: Mrs Bethan Evans

Rwyf yn gofrestru i wrthwynebu'r cynlluniau i adeiladu ar y safle SR/139/001 ac SR/139/002 ym Mhorthyrhyd. Fe symudes i a fy nheulu i'r pentre blwyddyn yn ôl gan wbod wrth y cyfreithwr ein bod ni yn symud i ardal oedd a phroblemau llifogydd, ac fy mhryder mwyaf yw bod hyn yn mynd i gael effaith ddifrifol ar y sefyllfa. Mae gen i dystiolaeth gan y cyfreithwr am hyn os bydd eisiau cyflwyno i'r adran.

Object

Representation ID: 397

Received: 03/02/2019

Respondent: Mrs Bethan Evans

Rwyf yn gofrestru i wrthwynebu'r cynlluniau i adeiladu ar y safle SR/139/002 ym Mhorthyrhyd. Fe symudes i a fy nheulu i'r pentre blwyddyn yn ôl, stmud i bentre tawel gwledig, ac yn pryderu fydd y cynllun yma yn dinistrio tir amaethyddol sydd yn amgylchynu'r Gerddi Fotaneg prydferth sydd gyda ni yma ar stepen drws. Bydd y cynnydd yn traffic yn effithio'r pentre yn fawr, gan gofio am yr holl bethau i blant sydd yn digwydd yn lleol (Adran Urdd, CFfI) plis ystyriwch hyn i gyd yn eich penderfyniad.

Object

Representation ID: 417

Received: 03/02/2019

Respondent: Mr Osian Evans

Rwy'n cofrestru i wrthwynebu'r cynlluniau yma. Fe symudais i a'n nheulu i bentre tawel a gwledig porthyrhyd blwyddyn yn ôl.
Bydd y cynllun yma'n golygu y bydd cynnydd yn y traffic a bydd hyn yn effithio'r pentre yn fawr. Mae'r groesffordd yn bryder yn barod, gan gofio am yr holl bethau i blant sydd yn digwydd yn lleol.
Bydd y cynllun yma hefyd yn dinistrio tir amaethyddol sydd yn amgylchynu'r Gerddi Fotaneg ar stepen ein drws.

Object

Representation ID: 439

Received: 03/02/2019

Respondent: Dr Caryl Thomas

Rear of middleton

Object

Representation ID: 535

Received: 04/02/2019

Respondent: Mrs Ann Rhys

Dwysedd: Pentref bach yw Porth-y-rhyd. Yn ol maint y safle hwn gellid adeiladu nifer sylweddol o dai arno, dros 30. Bydd y datblygiad arfaethedig yn anghydnaws a chymeriad gwledig y pentref gan gynyddu traffig ac arferion cymudo yn sylweddol. Ar ben hyn mae colled tir amaethyddol da yn mynd i ddigwydd.

Object

Representation ID: 644

Received: 05/02/2019

Respondent: Mr Gethin Harkin

I wish to register my opposition to the inclusion of both sites - SR/139/001 (Middleton-Bolgoed) and SR/139/002 (fields adjacent to Llwyn Henri) - in the revised local Development plan 2018-2033 due to the impact it will have on neighbouring properties and the impact of increased traffic through the village. I also have concerns regarding existing problems regarding surface water and floods due to developments due to take place on flood zones.

Object

Representation ID: 697

Received: 05/02/2019

Respondent: Mr Graham Tune

Size and Density of some 32 plus house.
The impact on neighbouring properties such as school has reached its capacity, the increase in the volume of traffic, this is not sustainable.

Object

Representation ID: 726

Received: 05/02/2019

Respondent: Lucy Georgiou

I wish to register my opposition to the development of site SR/139/002 in porthyrhyd. My major concern is the size of this proposed development and the effects this would have on the local population, in particular llanddarog school which serves this area. The school is already over capacity and a housing estate of over 30 houses would have a major impact on the ability of the school to accommodate local Children and is likely to effect current pupil's quality of education as the schools resources are overwhelmed.

Object

Representation ID: 765

Received: 06/02/2019

Respondent: Mrs Sara Jones

Myself and my husband object to this site being built in our quiet village of Porthyrhyd. It has a lovely community feel at the moment and we'd like to keep it that way - building more houses will increase traffic and commuting in the area. The proposed site will have a negative impact on neighbouring properties - 32 properties is a lot to build in such a small village which will change the feel of the community completely! The site will also cause loss of agricultural land in Porthyrhyd.

Object

Representation ID: 797

Received: 06/02/2019

Respondent: Mr Christopher Osborne

Traffic issues already exist, to my knowledge there hasn't been an accident yet, building 32+ properties will only increase the chances of something happening. The area is agricultural with livestock and wildlife very close, development will impact negatively on the local farms. Property values will be slashed and the ability to sell properties will become even harder. There is already a flooding issue, the development will only add to this. The development will only damage this community and have long term effects on the residents and the area, more vehicles will not be sustainable. I strenuously object to development.

Object

Representation ID: 903

Received: 06/02/2019

Respondent: Mrs Lesley Osborne

I object to planning in this area because of existing flood zone problems, putting 32+ properties in this area will only add to the problems. Local traffic issues exist around the MOT garage and the extra traffic from 32+ houses will only add to the issue. The land is agricultural and should stay as so. Building properties in this area will impact on the livestock and wildlife in an unsustainable way. The local farms are going to suffer terribly. Properties in the area will suffer from value loss making selling more difficult than it is now. No development please.

Object

Representation ID: 923

Received: 06/02/2019

Respondent: Mr Eifion Lewis

Flooding/Surface water - Close proximity of Gwendraeth Fach river identified as liable to flooding. NRW identified site within flood risk area categorised Zone C2 - TAN 15. Surface water issues due to general topography of site. Waterlogging and standing water.

Pollution - Greenfield site - Potential to overload current sewerage capacity.

Landscape/wildlife - Unwanted incursion into countryside and to detriment of landscape.

Devaluation of current settlements - loss of privacy and light.

Increased vehicular traffic - pollution - population increase.

SR/139/002 is NOT a natural extension of existing residential properties. Land used from an agricultural perspective with working small holding.

Object

Representation ID: 943

Received: 07/02/2019

Respondent: Mrs Linda Landry

I wish to register my opposition to the inclusion of SR/139/002 ( Fields adjacent to Llwyn Henri ) in the revised Local Development Plan 2018 - 2033.
Development of the site will lead to the loss of agricultural land and due to the size and density of the development will increase traffic and congestion in the village. It will impact on the existing adjacent properties, and put pressure on local services including local schools which are currently operating at full capacity. A development of this size is not sustainable.

Object

Representation ID: 1015

Received: 07/02/2019

Respondent: Mrs Miriam Biddle

I want to register my opposition to the inclusion of SR/139/002 ( Fields adjacent to Llwyn Henri) in the revised development plan 2018-2033. Development of this site will lead to loss of agricultural land. Due to the size & density of the proposed development it will impact on neighbouring properties , put stress on local services and increase traffic & congestion in the village. The local schools are already at full capacity and have waiting lists due to shortage of space. A development of this size is not sustainable

Object

Representation ID: 1018

Received: 07/02/2019

Respondent: Mrs Linda Landry

I wish to register my opposition to the inclusion of SR/139/002 ( Fields adjacent to Llwyn Henry) in the revised local development plan 2018-2033. The development will lead to loss of agricultural land and due to the size and density of the proposed development will impact on neighbouring properties as well as increase traffic and congestion in the village. It will also put stress on local services including schools which are already operating at full capacity. This development is not sustainable.

Object

Representation ID: 1037

Received: 07/02/2019

Respondent: Mrs Lynwen Jones

Hoffwn i wrthwynebu'n gryf yn erbyn y cynllun hwn. Mae'r un safle wedi cael ei wrthod yn y gorffennol am yr un rhesymau sydd dal yn bodoli heddiw. Problemau gyda dwr glaw a llifogydd yn barod. Problemau traffig a thrafnidiaeth yn barod ar yr heol- does dim lle i ddau gar pasio ei gilydd. Basai cynnydd o ran traffig a'r cymudo yn arwain at fwy o broblemau. Colli tir amaethyddol da yn enwedig y cae uchaf. Basai effaith cynyddol hefyd ar y tai cyfagos. Felly, nid yw'r cynllun hwn yn gynaliadwy o gwbl.

Object

Representation ID: 1045

Received: 07/02/2019

Respondent: Miss Fiona Morgan

I strongly object to the planning. It will cause more problems. I am constantly seeing flooded fields outside my windows and the thought of having more traffic on the road is very worrying as more traffic turning into entrances is an additional problem. There are enough traffic, loading and turning problems here already causing me to reverse and wait constantly.
The visual amenity of a rural village would be under threat, it would completely destroy the character of our neighbourhood. The extra noise and disturbance is also a big worry. I strongly object to the planning.

Object

Representation ID: 1177

Received: 07/02/2019

Respondent: Mrs Vivienne Albiston

I wish to register my opposition to the inclusion of both sites SR/139/001(middleton/bolgoed) and SR /139/002. Specifically I object to the density of housing planned with one portion of the land yet again being on a desgnated flood plain. Yet anothe piece of agricultural land will be lost, traffic on a small lane will inevitably increase. Infrastructure, specifically primary school capacity will not be able to accommodate increased numbers of children.

Object

Representation ID: 1200

Received: 07/02/2019

Respondent: Mrs Maria Williams

Proposed scale and density of development is not within character of the
current area. Residents of this area have chosen to live in rural
surroundings. This development does not fit the character of the area.

Roadway and access is inadequate for a development of this scale.

Loss quality agricultural land (top field)

Frequent issues with flooding and surface water (lower field). Site is not
suitable for development.

Considering the nearby development areas (Foelgastell and Cefneithin) it's
doubtful that there is demand for another development of this scale in the
area.

Object

Representation ID: 1217

Received: 07/02/2019

Respondent: Mr Matthew Butler

The Well-being of Future Generations (Wales) Act 2015 has 7 goals, of which one is supporting cohesive communities and another a vibrant culture and thriving Welsh language. Given the proposed number of dwellings I believe this would negatively impact an extremely strong community, in which supportive relationships thrive and the use of the Welsh language remains strong.
I also suspect there to be an adverse effect on traffic within the village.

Object

Representation ID: 1295

Received: 07/02/2019

Respondent: Mr Dafydd Jones

I object for numerous reasons. Porthyrhyd has got plenty of issues as it is without any additional developments.
Sewerage issues - The system is already having issues because of the population.
Safety issues - In reference to site development the location is off a narrow lane, no pavement and already finding it hard to deal with traffic congestion through transport.
Flood Zone - The lower field of this development is in the flood zone. Water travels down from the top and all drains naturally in that field.
This development would not be sustainable.

Object

Representation ID: 1317

Received: 08/02/2019

Respondent: Mr David Bryer

Mae'r tir ar gyfer y safle hwn yn ardal llifogydd

Object

Representation ID: 1559

Received: 08/02/2019

Respondent: Mr Robert Rhys

Maint y datblygiad arfaethedig a'i effeithiau ar dai cyfagos.

Object

Representation ID: 1599

Received: 08/02/2019

Respondent: Dr Goronwy Jones

Nid yw'r datblygiad arfaethedig yma yn gyson gyda Papur Pwnc Cyngor Caerfyrddin "Terfynau Datblygu" Para 3.8 ("parch at gymeriad pentref"; Para 4.3 ("gwledig v trefol") a Para 8.6 ("Gorlenwi")

Object

Representation ID: 1608

Received: 08/02/2019

Respondent: Ms Eirionwen Jenkins

Effaith ar dai cyfagos, colli tir amaethyddol da, a rhagor o drafnidiaeth i leoliad anghysbell.

Object

Representation ID: 1745

Received: 03/02/2019

Respondent: Enfys Davies

After many many years we are still experiencing problems at our property of excrement and the contents of the sewers and drains entering our garden through a hole in the ground.

The possibility of building more houses in the village leaves us with the feeling of dread and the impact of this on not just us but the village also. The flooding is also an issue which needs to be taken into account.

Wildlife will also be disrupted by further development.

Object

Representation ID: 1935

Received: 07/02/2019

Respondent: Mudiad Amddiffyn Porthyrhyd

Number of people: 189

Rydym yn mynegi ein pryderon dwys parthed yr ardrawiad amgylcheddol a'r problemau ewhangach a ddaw yn sgil datblygu'r ddau safle SR/139/001 a SR/139/002 ym mhentref Porth-y-rhyd.

Gwrthwynebwa gynnwys y safle yng Nghynllun Dablygu Lleol diwygiedig Sir Gaerfyrddin 2018-2033 a gofynnwn yn garedig i Adran Blaengynllunio Cyngor Sir Caerfyrddin chwilio am safleoedd addas i'w ddatblygu lle nad oes problemau.

We wish to register our severe concerns regarding the environmental and wider impact of both proposed developments SR/139/001 and SR/139/002 in the village of Porth-y-rhyd.

We object to the inclusion of these sites in the revised Carmarthenshire Local Development Plan 2018-2033 and respectfully ask the Forward Planning Department of Carmarthenshire County Council to seek suitable sites for development where no problems exist.

Object

Representation ID: 2056

Received: 08/02/2019

Respondent: Jonathan Edwards MP

Fields adjacent to Llwyn Henri. J Edwards MP states that his constituents believe that the building of 32+ houses would have an overbearing impact on the area and neighbouring properties. It is stated that development would not be sustainable due to the loss of an agricultural field and an increase in traffic and congestion. J Edwards MP trusts that CCC will consider these objections as part of the consultation process and that they will form part of CCC response and adjustments to the plan going forward.